Galasso's (Lebanon, NJ)
∙ Brooklyn Pizza (Pan Crust Pizza: EVO & Fresh Garlic Marinated Plum Tomatoes, Cheese & Fresh Basil) ∙ Arugula Pizza (Pan Crust Pizza: Baby Arugula, Grape Tomatoes, Diced Fresh Mozzarella, EVO & Shredded Sharp Provolone) ∙
Another repeat for what was my favorite NJ pizza restaurant. The original owners have retired and moved on with their business. I absolutely love these pizzas. I will miss their craft dearly.
Star Tavern (City of Orange, NJ)
∙ Pepperoni Pizza ∙
Whoa. WHOA. THIS IS THE BEST BAR PIE IN HISTORY.
I really can’t believe how flavorful this pie was, loaded with greasy pep and delicious saucy cheese on a super thin , almost cracker crust.
The pizza had a hint of smokiness like the char on a burger. It was incredible.
This pie is the reason you exercise. If you have a cheat day , park your rear here and gorge on this greasy gooey goodness.
It was the 3rd stop on the tour and we crushed the pizza. I will be returning to the landmark of City of Orange for this pie.
Coniglio's Old Fashioned (Morristown, NJ)
∙ JOSEPHINA’S GRANDMA (mozz, tomato sauce, basil, parm) ∙
Yeah, we’ve done this before. Who cares? This is the best place in NJ. Could have eaten the entire pie and it was the second pizza spot on the tour.
DeLucia's Brick Oven Pizza (Raritan, NJ)
Cheese Pizza
Sold out when we arrived at 1pm on a Friday afternoon, 90 minutes after opening. The oven dates back to 1917!